This Story is Archived
10 myths -- and 10 truths -- about atheism »
Posted by: msaleem 1 year, 8 months agoHere are 10 myths and 10 truths.
Read Full Story at latimes.com »
This Story is Archived and Commenting is Closed
Comments: 215
-


blazemark
Dec. 24, 2006, 9:36 p.m.A moral upstanding ethical athiest.Good joke.I mean why?The problem with athiests is that they exude a deadness.A dryness of the bones.
-


jeffery1
Dec. 25, 2006, 2:14 p.m.Howdt, I'm an atheist or actually an ardent agnostic because I really don't know whether god exists or not. In truth, all religious people are agnostics because they don't know either, they merely believe deeply. I am very moral and have a very firm foundation for it. I would love to know just what you mean by "exude a deadness. a dryness of the bones." Care to clarify this?
-
-


2sidestoeverything
Dec. 24, 2006, 10:36 p.m.Interesting article it was enlightening. I don't know why people think you can't be a good moral person if you don't believe in God. Many wars are started in the name of God and I haven't heard of any wars starting in the name of science.
-


teebig
Dec. 25, 2006, 10:23 a.m.2sidestoeverything, I will tell you why there is a conflict between atheism and morality, and it is quite simple: God is the God of morals, not men. Men cannot determine what is right or what is wrong w/o divine instruction. Haven't you heard the old cliche', the path to hell is paved w/good intentions? Determining right or wrong cannot be left up to human-beings because morals are then degraded and reduced to nothing more than a point of view, per individual, and I am certain you can foresee the danger in this. Take Hitler, do you think that he thought what he did was wrong? With children, they don't know right from wrong, but the enlightenment is passed down from their parents, from their parents. We, the human race are like children to God. We have to be taught. And lastly, whatever men know to be morally righteous is spiritually given to them from God. And even then one must consult w/God for reassurrance. Read the bible. Get to know God; God is the God of righteousness.
-


PaganGodess
Dec. 25, 2006, 12:49 p.m.{{Many wars are started in the name of God and I haven't heard of any wars starting in the name of science.}}
Well said! = ]
-
-


earthlingerer
Dec. 25, 2006, 9:56 a.m.You definitely don't have to believe in ANY god to find the evolutionary and common human values in the ten commandments.
-


teebig
Dec. 25, 2006, 10:30 a.m.Hmm. Whether you believe in God or not, the Ten Commandments was given from God. How could you believe in the value of the Ten Commandments and not believe in God? God is the Ten Commandments, and more! God is His Word, like, a man who is a man of His word. How can you take the good that someone gives you and not give them credit for it?
-
-


thestarryhunter
Dec. 25, 2006, 10:22 a.m.(John 1:1). when its all said and done,HE will have the final word.
-
-


thestarryhunter
Dec. 25, 2006, 10:44 a.m.i truly believe that John 1:5 explains the condition of the world. "And the light shineth in darkness; and the the darkness comprehendred it not"
-


teebig
Dec. 25, 2006, 11:08 a.m.Absolutely! The thing I would have to say about this is, HOW CAN YOU NOT BELIEVE THIS :-)?
-


thestarryhunter
Dec. 25, 2006, 10:54 a.m.its amazing. almost all or at least all the athiests i know,when it comes down to crunch time,whose name do they call out too? also if they you dont believe in Christ why would you curse HIM so? and dont give that "its a generic form of cursing"
-


Beau7890
Dec. 25, 2006, 11:16 a.m.Now, wait a minute, thestarryhunter--as the article states (and as I've noticed from my encounters with athiests), no one is cursing God. To not believe is not the same as to curse him or to curse those who do believe.
As I was going to say in response to your above comment, "all we can do is love 'em..."--that's the right attitude. When you paint athiests as cursing God, rather than peacefully tolerating those of differing beliefs, you're judging, not necessarily loving.
-


bcellboy
Dec. 25, 2006, 10:27 p.m."almost all or at least all the athiests i know,when it comes down to crunch time,whose name do they call out too?"
How many people have you killed?
-
-


thestarryhunter
Dec. 25, 2006, 11:03 a.m.satan is the author of confusion, and he sure is doing a good job of it!!
-


teebig
Dec. 25, 2006, 11:11 a.m.Yes, unfortunately. But we as Christians must see for them, as long as we allow the Lord to see for us. I feel pity for those who do not believe, both atheist and fairweather Christians; they don't realize how much they are missing.
-

HmacComment has been removed: User banned.
-
-


defender35
Dec. 25, 2006, 11:18 a.m.Being God was the tempters tactic in Genesis, "for you will be like God, knowing good and evil." Atheistic belief is indeed responsible for the actions of Hitler, Mao, Pol Pot, and Stalin. Don't be fooled. What is theologically implicit in Darwinism is the rejection of the Almighty God to whom we must be held accountable.
As a Seminary professor once stated, "idolatry and immorality are two sides of the same coin; if you get your worship wrong, you get your morality wrong as well."
God's existance depends not on atheistic opinions but upon the promise of his Word, "for he who comes to God must believe that his is and that He is a rewarder of those who diligently seek him" (Hebrews 11:6).
-
-


JohnBryansFontaine
Dec. 25, 2006, 2:29 p.m.Again I state:
As he was neither Liberal, Progressive, Socialistic, Communistic, Jewish, nor Gay, Hitler was also NOT an atheist. There are any number of references to both God and Christ in Mein Kampf, Hitler stated that he considered himself to be a Catholic and the Nazis celebrated Christmas.
Why must( usually ) conservatives keep coming up with all these Lies about Hitler?
-
-


frownonfun
Dec. 25, 2006, 11:21 a.m.ok yeah i'm an atheist and i neither praise nor curse any god. i own all of my accomplishments as do i own all of my shortcomings. i don't need to acknowledge a god to lead a life in keeping with the good of mankind. god may equate peace and love but peace and love do not have to equate god for all of us. i think it is unfortunate that christians think it is ok to unite and demonize those who don't believe what they do. i'm not sure that's what a god, who is said to love all his children, would want.
-


Beau7890
Dec. 25, 2006, 11:45 a.m.Thank you, frownonfun. Not all athiests are antagonistic toward people who believe in God, or a god, just as not all those who believe are antagonistic toward athiests.
And to those believers who would speak against athiests, what about Luke 6:37 -- "Judge not, and ye shall not be judged: condemn not, and ye shall not be condemned: forgive, and ye shall be forgiven."
-


teebig
Dec. 25, 2006, 1:24 p.m.You already cursed God w/o knowing it. You said you neither curse nor praise Him. Then you state, "i don't need to acknowledge a god to lead a life in keeping with the good of mankind." You don't need to acknowledge God?! So when God finally comes as it is prophecied in Scriptures, and He sees your quote, can you honestly look Him in the eyes and say, "I wasn't cursing you?" You are turning your back to Him. Whatever good you have, God gave it to you. Be careful to whom you give the credit, the praise, and the glory for your accomplishments. God can easily take away what He gives, all is His!
-
-


Qukatt
Dec. 25, 2006, 11:58 a.m.Of course there's no mention of the difference between being Athiest and Agnostic in that but it's a good article nevertheless.
for the record - > Agnosticish/Jewish-Chemist ^_^
-


bcellboy
Dec. 25, 2006, 12:40 p.m.this is why atheists can't argue with people of religion, using God did it, or God said it is not a rational argument because it cannot be proved or disproved.
And you don't need religion to lead a moral life: I don't lie, cheat or steal because it is wrong, not because God told me not to. In addition, I've done more volunteer work than I can remember because I felt I owed it to my fellow man, not because I thought it was a ticket into heaven.
-


PaganGodess
Dec. 25, 2006, 12:59 p.m.{{This is why atheists can't argue with people of religion, using God did it, or God said it is not a rational argument because it cannot be proved or disproved.}}
Excellently and diplomatically said!
-


teebig
Dec. 25, 2006, 1:46 p.m.bcellboy, were you born knowing lying, cheating, stealing, and whatever is wrong? Somewhere, you had to learn it was wrong. But anyway, learn about God and you will not only refrain from doing wrong, but do a whole lot of good. I'm a Christian bcellboy, you can argue with me. Warning though, I don't like to argue, but reason. Love is the heart of reason, and God is love.
-
-


nightflyer
Dec. 25, 2006, 12:47 p.m.I am still amazed whenever I see commentaries like these. "How can you be moral? You don't believe in God! How can you believe the Ten Commandments have value if you don't believe in God?"
How arrogant. I haven't believed in God even as a kid, but still, I managed to be a good person, not go out on killing sprees or become a criminal or something like that. Shocking, I know. How did this happen?
I'll tell you how. Because I have a brain. Because I'm a responsible human being. Because it doesn't take a belief in god to tell the difference between what is wrong (ie, actions that hurt others) and what is right (actions that either don't hurt or actually help others).
I have to ask - those of you who believe that your religion is the reason you're "good" people - do you honestly believe that you would be unable to tell the difference without religion?
Religion has been used as an excuse for slavery, repression, racism, torture and murder throughout history. And I'm not talking way way back, either - people still use it to excuse all these actions today. Not just "the other guys" - people who call themselves Christians, too. Or do you think clinic bombings and assassinations of doctors who provide abortions just kinda happened?
And howzabout all those upstanding religious leaders and individuals who keep getting caught with their pants down, sometimes literally? Religion sure didn't help them become good guys - although it did make them, oh, what's the word.... oh, yeah, hypocrites. Hmmm.... wasn't theere a long-haired religious figure who didn't much like hypocrites?
As to the 10 commandments, what's so tough about figuring out the value? Don't steal, don't kill, don't nail the neighbor's wife, etc. These aren't exactly complex philosophical debates. And you don't need the Bible or the Torah or anything else to figure this stuff out. Well, I don't, anyway. Maybe you guys do. And if that's the case, then what does that say about you?
-


defender35
Dec. 25, 2006, 1:37 p.m.You are correct. You don't need to have someone tell you right and wrong. Our conscience convicts us of an exterior standard of rightness. This is beyond you and me, and beyond all others. The universality of this moral ought should be enough to convict all mankind of a Moral God. It is this moral lawgiver to whom we must give an account. And we have missed the mark.
Jesus didn't miss the mark, though. And when we acknowledge the existance of God, submit to his supremacy and moral authority, repent from our ways and turn to God's ways, then by faith in Jesus (his substitution for our rebellion) we have available for us all the blessings and truth of God himself. Jesus was the God-man. He reconciled us to God.
-
-


Goppy
Dec. 25, 2006, 12:52 p.m.The difference between Atheists and Christians is one important thing.
God has treated us Christians to a special preview of the entire 2007 season of The TODAY Show.
Belive me, it's not pretty, and it will continue to look bleak for you atheists.
Better consider your afterlife status now!!
Because you KNOW how it ends!
-


CriticalTheorist
Dec. 25, 2006, 1:13 p.m.I can see from this thread that, in spite of Sam Harris's excellent article, very few posters understand atheism. To those who want to know more or are curious about atheism, I invite you to go to internetinfidels.org and proceed to its forum. There you will find many atheists to discuss issues with. It's the best discussion forum on the web!!!
-


JohnBryansFontaine
Dec. 25, 2006, 2:44 p.m.Seeing the ad in the NY Times for Harris' book 'Letter to a Christian Nation', I was offended by the headline: Religion = Madness.
I would ask Harris and all the other PC-Stalinist atheists, if their glorious atheism is so Rational, then why did an atheist recently set himself on fire, over something being named for Christmas and Easter, instead of winter and spring??
-
-


Daylight
Dec. 25, 2006, 1:18 p.m.Albert1
Your saying people dont learn by their mistakes but only from Gods intervention. Keep in mind God didn't write the bible MAN did.
That is the reason it is flawed, and needs to be revised all the time, and call it Revised Version, it is a version, inspiration comes in different version, I certainly agree with most of your argument about God, but when you say your Bible is inspired by God I will not agree with you, because if it has been inspired by God you won't find errors and phonographic materials in that book, if you need I can give a list of references, the name Bible is not given by God it means library of books. Written by many people and they all have different things to say for why they had to write.
-


defender35
Dec. 29, 2006, 1:39 a.m.Albert,
In all sincerity, you've approached the Bible with much skepticism.
Here's some questions any reasonable and well though atheist should be able to answer:
1) Where did evil come from?
2) If atheism is "universal truth", how has atheism benefitted mankind as a whole.
3) Why does mankind long for supernatural things while other life forms don't.
4)Why is earth centered at the proper distance from the sun? Any closer we'd burn; any further we'd freeze to death.
5)Why can't man measure up to the standard which he expects of others? Maybe a universal moral standard? A personal God, perhaps?
6) Why are we able to partake of nature: it's beauty, scent, magnificance, granduer? I think something (or Someone?) is wooing us.
I hope you'll consider those thoughts despite your assumptions against God. Atheism should be able to answer those if it is indeed "truth".
-
-


PaganGodess
Dec. 25, 2006, 1:23 p.m.Good article explaining the scientific mind. Scientists must rely on empirical evidence which I can understand completely.
Religion and spirituality are deeply personal choices that everyone is free to make for themselves. I think mankind intuitively knows what is right and wrong and I suspect we have for a long time! Does that mean we always do it? Nope - and we never will. That's the nature of being human.
I respect the beliefs of others even if they disagree with my own. What I do not respect is people trying to shove THEIR religious beliefs on me as being the "ONE RIGHT AND ONLY" way, dictating to me what THEY believe my afterlife will be like as a result of not agreeing with them or presuming to know what I believe and tossing ignorant insults at me in the process.
FYI - the only person who will KNOW, beyond a shadow of a doubt what YOUR afterlife will look like is you and you won't live to tell us about it. = ]
-


teebig
Dec. 25, 2006, 2:27 p.m.Whatever men know that is true, God implanted it there; afterall, is He not our Creator? Whatever we are that is good, He gave it to us. Whatever we are not, God chose to withhold it from us. Do you know that in the beginning, and when I say beginning, I mean the days of Adam, that there were no bibles, nor churches, nor temples? But there was God and His Word. And as soon as we decided to go off and do things on our own by disobeying what God commanded us not to do, behold, we have the Ten Commandments, bibles, churches, etc. The point is, men need instruction, it was proven in the Garden of Eden. But there will come a time, when things will be made new, and restored to prestine times, and there will again be no church, no bible, no priest, because we will be in the presence of God Himself, and there will be no need of such things. He will again instruct us directly.
-
